Manchester United leading the race for Carlos Baleba as player preference becomes clear

Carlos Baleba is understood to prefer a move to Manchester United, with optimism building that the clubs will open structured talks ahead of the summer window. Brighton are expected to hold firm on a premium valuation, reflecting his age, upside and long contract. United view Baleba as a dynamic ball-winning 6-8 who can raise the team’s pressing intensity and protect transitions, fitting cleanly next to a progressive controller. The message from informed voices is simple: United are in the lead, and any rival push is a long shot. If the numbers align, this is a deal with clear green lights.

Respected reporter Ben Jacobs indicated that Carlos Baleba’s preference is Manchester United, adding that it would be a surprise if he chose a rival. Brighton’s stance remains consistent with their transfer model for young, high-upside midfielders on long contracts. United have been tracking a ball-winning profile to complement their core and are preparing for a summer recalibration of the midfield. Market context matters here: Brighton typically sell on their terms, but player preference and a clear footballing fit often accelerate dialogue once the window framework opens.

🚨🗣️ @JacobsBen: "Carlos Baleba wants Manchester United, and personally, I think it would be a big surprise if two clubs one Man United and one arrival, agree a fee with Brighton. I think it would be unlikely that Carlos Baleba would pick that other club over Manchester

@UtdXclusive

Impact Analysis

From a footballing perspective, this move makes sense. Baleba brings high energy, duel power and repeat sprints that United have lacked in defensive transition phases. He profiles as a modern hybrid 6-8 who thrives in pressing triggers, closes passing lanes and still carries the ball through contact. In practical terms, he reduces exposure in United’s rest-defense, shortens the pitch for opposing counters and gives the back line an extra layer of protection. Pairing him with a controller or with a progressive all-phase midfielder allows the team to tilt the field without conceding central space.

United’s recruitment under the new structure has emphasized age curve, recoverability of value and role clarity. Baleba, 21, ticks those boxes. He has Premier League minutes, development headroom and the Brighton schooling that stresses patterns under pressure. Financially, Brighton’s long-term contract leverage means a premium fee is likely, but amortization and a performance-weighted structure can align with PSR. The key risk is execution in build-up against set blocks, where his decision speed must stay sharp, but United can manage that through role definition and spacing. On balance, the football and data arguments point strongly to fit and upside.

Reaction

Fans read this as United’s move to lose. One thread sums it up: “Another day, another midfielder,” followed by calls to fix the defense first. There’s also confidence anchored to the player’s preference: several users claim any rival bid is a “long shot” if the midfielder wants Old Trafford. A few point to Brighton’s tough stance and float a nine-figure tag, while others joke about a growing African core at United, name-checking Amad and Onana, even tossing in Semenyo, Mbeumo and Mazraoui for laughs.

Some push back. One comment says United should walk away if the price balloons. Another queries a confusing “arrival - another club?” phrasing, which people read as a slip meaning “rival.” The dominant mood, though, is bullish: “Everyone wants to play for the biggest club in the world.” A minority worries about priorities and cost sequencing, but the consensus online is that preference plus fit gives United pole position. Negotiation time, not desire, is seen as the obstacle.

Social reactions

If the plan is to move Bruno on, his direct replacement in terms of ability from deep, has to be Stiller. Now get Baleba to play alongside Stiller might be okay but I worry about the balance with both being left footed.

ғʀᴇᴅᴅʏ (@FlexiBars)

This Jacobs guy is not serious! All of a sudden United want to add two African players to the lot we already have in the first team. I trust Sir Ratcliffe to make a good business decision.

Georgee (@georgeeSpikey)

This potential transfer concerns me. Since Baleba was linked to Utd his form has gone off a cliff, it brings into question if he has the mentality to play for us.

Sam Brown 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 (@SamBrow74823937)

Prediction

Baseline scenario: United progress informal alignment with the player’s side in spring, then open club-to-club talks early in the window. Brighton set a high anchor, United counter with a structured package built on achievable add-ons and a sell-on. If preference remains firm and no Champions League heavyweight crashes the race, a deal can be closed before preseason to integrate Baleba’s role.

Alternative scenario: Valuation gap persists into mid-window. United hold, monitor parallel targets and apply timing pressure. Player preference keeps the door open, but Brighton’s leverage delays closure. Outcome shifts to late-window once other dominoes fall.

Low-probability scenario: A rival returns with guaranteed cash above United’s structure. Even then, the player’s stance could be decisive. If United match the headline value through add-ons, their sporting plan wins. Expect noise around figures, but the most logical pathway is United finding agreement via performance clauses and amortization that satisfy PSR and Brighton’s model.

Latest today

• Manchester United Reaffirm Bruno Fernandes Is Not For Sale - Captain Anchored In Long-Term...
• Brighton cannot recall Carl Rushworth in January - season-long Coventry loan stands
• Man United clarify timing of Bruno Fernandes interview as summer exit talk resurfaces
• Kylian Mbappé wins €61m ruling against PSG - financial and sporting fallout

Conclusion

All signs point one way: United first, others distant. The football case is obvious. Baleba’s engine, ball-winning and carry-through-contact fit the gaps that show up on United’s worst days - loose counters, second balls, broken structure. The market case holds too. Brighton will not blink on valuation, but they do sell at the right number, and player preference turns a difficult deal into an executable one.

United’s midfield needs a young anchor with legs who can live in high-press moments without sacrificing control. Baleba matches that brief. If United stay disciplined on structure and early timing, they can land a starter for the next cycle, not just a depth piece. Expect a firm stance from Brighton, expect headlines about price, but also expect momentum to hold. This is the right profile at the right age, in the right league, with the right trajectory. It reads like a deal that gets done.